Видео

Fire the sound guy.

And Simon was 100% correct: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_Idol_alumni_album_sales_in_the_United_States

They threw everything they had at this performance. String orchestra, top backup singer, nuclear dummer, seismic bassist and some white noise added to the refrain. They knew what they had well in advance.

3:03 Grossed out that Seacrest pinched her... LOL!!!

Carrie has had adjustments bless her heart

Bo Bice ,,, American Idol was yours from day "One.". You didn't get it, because it was rigged. Carrie Underwood bless her heart is fake as a $3.00 bill

Le falta potencia en la voz para este tema

Ryan is a cutie

This is such a time capsule. The hair (Ryan’s), the outfits, everything!

When I first saw her singing on Idol, I was like "ew this girl is boring", but now she's one of very few celebrities that I actually respect. Love her.

this is literally where she won that competition. Still get chills from it. She became a star right in this moment. You could tell at first she is a bit nervous. Not only is this a big/tough song but she had just been the shy, quiet, young country girl before this. She needed to be BIG here in every way. And you can see the moment in the song where she puts her nerves aside and let's her full voice/talent out. It's quite extraordinary, to be honest. Very few stars have a public moment where you can see them emerge into this new place. This was hers.

She has always been great. You can look up her high school performance of a Whitney Houston song. Also this is the early days of the house band. It felt pretty sloppy but as time went on they became an all star band. Now the band is one of the best I've ever heard.

And now she’s gonna be a judge on American idol

Just once I want to be at a concert where somebody completely unexpected shows up and performs.

Raw, rare and beautiful

Well tears 😢 Simon’s comment and now she is going to be a judge ❤

As good as Carrie is, she still can’t top Ann Wilson. Props to the female g.o.a.t. of rock anthem singers!!!

It’s 2024 and I still come back to watch this performance. The best American idol performance of all time!!!

It’s crazy to think she wants still on that same stage as a contestant and now next season she’s coming back as a judge really a full circle moment

Wow simonn❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Naive peasants think this isn’t staged… 👎🏻

Sorry but not a Wilson.....❤❤❤❤

She did a fantastic version of this song, hands down. I like kelly clarkson, but personally, i always thought carrie was a better singer.

What’s up with that background singer?????

This performance still chills me to bone 19 years later

Carrie's hair is so on point to be singing a Heart song 😍

The back up singer was better

at 1:05 the backup singer adds her part.....you can see the first DIVA moment of Carrie when she glances over like, "girl, back off".....

they did her dirty with that hair

Arrive had that IT FACTOR. She was so consistent. Ready for the studio and stage from Day One.

Great upload. I haven't seen this clip THIS clear since I watched the show during season 4.

It is a sad world when 1 MAN;S word directs a persons life. Something wrong here!

❤😊

She will NEVER be Ann!!!

Lack of fire/energy compared to Anne Wilson - original track. Like a small 3 cilinder engine instead a good V6, on a race track.

Carrie Underwood reminds me of Kelly Clarkson!

what were they thinking with that hair even for 2004 thats wild.. maybe cause its an 80s song lol

She ain’t no Ann Wilson

who 2as the back up on that song!

How hot

Nah LeeAnn Rimes best yodeler

No a patch on ann

I had chills the entire time 💜

Simon is the Gordon Ramsey of music production lol. Both know their shit fr

Still one of the best idol performances ever!!!! Top 3 for sure!!

That backup singer was better. Why isn’t she in American idol.

She is a good singer but I did not care for this cover.

She cleans up right nice, I think she might have future!

she is so Beautiful!!!

Simon was not correct. We beg the differ she should never open up her paper anymore